Top Pizza Places in Johnstown, Ohio: A Local’s Guide

Pizza Cottage

Pizza Cottage is a local favorite, and for good reason. They’ve been around for a while, and people seem to really love their pizza. It’s one of those places that comes up a lot when you ask about the best pizza in Johnstown Ohio, Newark Ohio, or even Heath Ohio. They have a distinctive taste that sets them apart from the chain places.

Pizza Cottage is more than just a pizza joint; it’s a community hub. You often see families and sports teams gathering there after games. It’s got that small-town feel that people appreciate.

Here’s what makes Pizza Cottage stand out:

• Their crust is a good balance of crispy and chewy.
• They use quality ingredients, which makes a difference.
• The sauce has a unique flavor profile that’s not too sweet or too acidic.

Let’s talk about pizza sizes. If you’re wondering how many slices in a large pizza from Pizza Cottage, it usually comes down to 12 slices. Of course, that can vary a bit depending on how they cut it, but that’s the standard. It’s perfect for sharing with a group, or if you’re really hungry!

Pizza Cottage is often in the conversation when talking about the best pizza ohio has to offer. It’s definitely worth checking out if you’re in the area.

Donato’s Pizza

Donato’s is another popular choice around here, and you can find them not just in Johnstown, but also in Heath and Newark. They’re known for their thin-crust pizza and the fact that they put their toppings edge-to-edge. It’s a chain, sure, but they’ve got a loyal following. I think it’s because they’re consistent; you know what you’re getting every time.

They’re not usually in the conversation for the best pizza in Ohio, but they are a solid option if you’re looking for something reliable. Plus, they have a bunch of different toppings and specialty pizzas to choose from. I’ve always been a fan of their Founder’s Favorite. It’s got pepperoni and sausage, and it’s always cooked just right.

I remember one time, we ordered Donato’s for a party, and everyone was happy. Even the picky eaters found something they liked. It’s a good crowd-pleaser, and you can’t really go wrong with it. It’s not the most amazing pizza you’ll ever have, but it’s definitely a good choice for a casual night in.

Here’s a quick rundown of some of their pizza sizes:

• Small (10″) – 6 slices
• Medium (12″) – 8 slices
• Large (14″) – 10 slices
• Extra Large (16″) – 12 slices

So, if you’re wondering how many slices in a large pizza from Donato’s, it’s usually 10. They also have salads, subs, and appetizers, so there’s something for everyone. If you’re looking for the best pizza in Johnstown Ohio, or even the best pizza in Heath Ohio or the best pizza in Newark Ohio, Donato’s is worth considering, especially if you like thin crust.

Domino’s Pizza

Domino’s is a big name, and you probably already know what to expect. It’s a reliable option when you need something quick and familiar. They’re all over the place, so finding one isn’t usually a problem. It might not be the best pizza in Johnstown Ohio, but it’s consistent.

• Easy online ordering
• Lots of coupons and deals
• Fast delivery

Domino’s is a good choice if you’re feeding a crowd and don’t want to spend a ton of money. They always have some kind of special going on, and the app makes it super easy to order. Plus, everyone knows what Domino’s tastes like, so there are no surprises.

Let’s talk about pizza sizes. How many slices in a large pizza from Domino’s? Usually, you’re looking at 12 slices. That’s pretty standard. Of course, the size of the slices can vary a bit depending on who’s cutting the pizza. It’s not the best pizza in Heath Ohio or the best pizza in Newark Ohio, but it’s there when you need it. Domino’s is Domino’s. You get what you pay for, and sometimes that’s exactly what you want. It’s not trying to be the best pizza ohio has to offer, but it fills a need.

Papa John’s Pizza

Papa John’s is a well-known chain, and you can find one in Johnstown. It’s a solid option if you’re looking for something familiar and consistent. They’re known for their dipping sauce, which some people really love. It’s not necessarily the best pizza in Johnstown Ohio, but it’s reliable.

They have a pretty big menu, so there’s usually something for everyone. From their original crust to thin crust, and a bunch of different toppings, you can customize your pizza pretty easily. Plus, they often have deals and specials, which can make it a budget-friendly choice. I think the question of how many slices in a large pizza depends on how you cut it, but usually, it’s around 8.

Papa John’s is a decent choice when you need something quick and easy. It might not be the most amazing pizza you’ve ever had, but it’s consistent and gets the job done. Sometimes, that’s all you really need.

Here’s a quick rundown of why people choose Papa John’s:

• Consistent quality across locations.
• Wide variety of toppings and crust options.
• Frequent deals and discounts.
• Easy online ordering and delivery.

While it might not be the best pizza in Heath Ohio or the best pizza in Newark Ohio, it’s a dependable option. It’s definitely not the best pizza ohio has to offer, but it’s a good choice for a quick and easy meal.

5. Little Caesars Pizza

Little Caesars is known for its HOT-N-READY pizzas, making it a super convenient option when you need something quick and easy. It’s definitely a go-to for a fast meal, especially if you’re feeding a crowd on a budget. While it might not be the place you go for gourmet, it’s reliable and consistent. You can always count on getting a decent pizza without breaking the bank. It’s a solid choice if you’re looking for something fast and affordable, and it’s a popular option for families and groups. It’s not necessarily the best pizza ohio has to offer, but it’s hard to beat for convenience.

Little Caesars is a great option when you need a quick and affordable meal. It’s not the fanciest pizza, but it’s reliable and consistent, making it a popular choice for families and groups.

Here are a few reasons why people choose Little Caesars:

• Price: It’s one of the most affordable pizza options around.
• Speed: The HOT-N-READY system means you can often walk in and out with a pizza in minutes.
• Convenience: With locations all over, it’s easy to find a Little Caesars nearby.

And if you’re wondering how many slices you’ll get, a large pizza typically has 8 slices. While it might not be the best pizza in Johnstown Ohio, best pizza in Heath Ohio, or best pizza in Newark Ohio, it’s a solid choice for a quick and easy meal.

Marco’s Pizza

Marco’s Pizza is another popular chain option in Johnstown. It’s known for its focus on fresh ingredients and a variety of specialty pizzas. You can usually find deals and coupons to make it a more budget-friendly choice. Is it the best pizza in Johnstown Ohio? That’s up for debate, but it’s definitely a contender.

Marco’s is a solid choice if you’re looking for something different from the usual suspects. They have a good range of toppings and crust options, and their sauce has a distinctive flavor. It’s a reliable option when you need a quick and easy meal. Plus, they often have some pretty good deals going on, which is always a bonus.

I’ve ordered from Marco’s a few times when I’m craving something other than the usual pizza chains. It’s not my absolute favorite, but it’s consistently decent, and the prices are reasonable. I appreciate that they use fresh ingredients, and their specialty pizzas are worth trying.

Here are a few things that make Marco’s stand out:

• Variety of specialty pizzas
• Focus on fresh ingredients
• Frequent deals and coupons

While some might argue about whether it’s the best pizza in Heath Ohio or the best pizza in Newark Ohio, Marco’s holds its own in Johnstown. It’s a decent option if you’re looking for something quick and easy. Plus, you can always customize your pizza to your liking. And if you’re wondering how many slices in a large pizza from Marco’s, it’s usually around 8, but it can depend on how they cut it. Is it the best pizza ohio has to offer? That’s a tough question, but it’s worth a try if you’re in the area.

Pizza Hut

Pizza Hut is a classic, and it’s been around for ages. You know what you’re getting, and sometimes that’s exactly what you want. It’s not necessarily the best pizza in Johnstown Ohio, but it’s reliable and usually pretty quick.

Pizza Hut is a solid option when you need something familiar and fast. It’s not going to blow your mind, but it will satisfy your pizza craving without breaking the bank. Plus, they always have deals going on, which is a nice bonus.

Here’s a few things that make Pizza Hut a decent choice:

• Deals and coupons are almost always available.
• They offer a variety of crusts and toppings.
• It’s a convenient option for delivery or carryout.

Speaking of toppings, they have a ton. And if you’re wondering how many slices in a large pizza, it’s usually 8, but sometimes they cut it into 12 depending on the style. It’s not the best pizza in Heath Ohio or the best pizza in Newark Ohio, but it’s a decent option if you’re in a hurry. It’s definitely not the best pizza ohio has to offer, but it’s a classic for a reason.

Giannino’s Pizzeria

Giannino’s Pizzeria is another solid option if you’re hunting for the best pizza in Johnstown Ohio. It’s a local favorite, and for good reason. They’ve been around for a while, consistently putting out quality pies. It’s a great place to grab a quick lunch or a family dinner. They are definitely in the running for best pizza in Newark Ohio, too, since it’s not too far away.

I remember one time, my family ordered a few pizzas from Giannino’s for a birthday party. We got a large pepperoni, a veggie pizza, and a cheese pizza for the kids. Everyone loved it, and there were barely any leftovers. It’s always a hit.

Here are a few reasons why Giannino’s is worth checking out:

• Consistent quality
• Good variety of toppings
• Family-friendly atmosphere

Let’s talk about pizza sizes. If you’re wondering how many slices in a large pizza, it usually depends on the place, but most places cut a large pizza into 8 or 10 slices. Giannino’s is no exception. They also have some pretty good deals if you’re looking to save a few bucks. While it might not be the best pizza in Heath Ohio, it’s still a great choice.

The Pizza Oven

Okay, so The Pizza Oven is another local spot that people seem to either really love or just think is okay. It’s been around for a while, which usually says something about a place, right? I mean, if you’re serving up bad pizza, you’re not going to last long, especially when there are so many options for the best pizza in Johnstown Ohio.

They’ve got a pretty standard menu, nothing too crazy, but sometimes that’s exactly what you want. You know, just a good, solid pizza without all the fancy toppings and weird combinations. It’s a reliable choice if you’re trying to figure out where to get pizza for a group and you don’t want to take any risks. Plus, they usually have some decent deals going on, which is always a bonus.

I remember one time we ordered from The Pizza Oven for a party, and everyone was happy. No complaints, just good, simple pizza. Sometimes that’s all you need. It’s not going to blow your mind, but it’s a solid choice.

Here’s a quick rundown of what you might expect:

• Classic toppings like pepperoni, sausage, and mushrooms
• A few specialty pizzas with different sauce and cheese combinations
• Sides like breadsticks and wings
• Delivery and carryout options

And if you’re wondering how many slices in a large pizza from The Pizza Oven, it’s usually the standard eight. So, you can plan accordingly when you’re ordering for a crowd. It’s not the best pizza in Heath Ohio or the best pizza in Newark Ohio, but it’s a decent option if you’re in Johnstown and looking for something quick and easy. It’s definitely worth checking out if you haven’t already. You might just find your new go-to spot for the best pizza ohio.

 J’s Pizza and More

J’s Pizza and More is a local spot that’s been around for a while, and it’s got a loyal following. It’s not just pizza; they have a pretty extensive menu with all sorts of stuff. If you’re looking for something beyond the usual chain experience, this might be your place. They are not going to be on any list of the best pizza in Ohio, but they are a solid choice for a quick bite.

They have a good variety of pizzas, from classic pepperoni to some more interesting combinations. I think they are a good option if you are looking for something different than the usual. It’s a good place to try if you are looking for the best pizza in Newark Ohio or the best pizza in Heath Ohio.

I’ve always found their service to be friendly, and the food is consistently good. It’s a reliable option when you just want something easy and satisfying.

Here are a few reasons why people like J’s Pizza and More:

• Good variety of toppings
• Friendly service
• Decent prices

And if you’re wondering how many slices in a large pizza, it’s usually around 8, but it can vary depending on how they cut it. If you are looking for the best pizza in Johnstown Ohio, this is a good place to start.

Wrapping It Up

So there you have it, folks! If you’re in Johnstown and craving some pizza, you’ve got plenty of great spots to check out. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic slice or something a bit different, these places have got you covered. Don’t forget to try a few different toppings and maybe even bring a friend or two along. Pizza is always better when shared, right? So grab your phone, call up your favorite place, and enjoy a delicious meal. Happy eating!